For Connecticut business owners
3(38) Investment Management for Small-Business 401(k) Plans
When you sponsor a 401(k), choosing and watching over the investment menu is a fiduciary responsibility. A 3(38) investment manager takes on that work, with discretion to select, monitor and replace funds, so you are not left making investment calls you never trained for.
Choosing 401(k) investments is a fiduciary job
Under ERISA, the people responsible for a retirement plan must act prudently and solely in the interest of participants. For the investment menu, that means selecting suitable options, monitoring them, and replacing ones that no longer measure up. The Department of Labor's guide, Meeting Your Fiduciary Responsibilities, describes those duties and notes that employers can hire experts to help carry them out.
Many small-business owners took on that role without realizing it when they signed the plan paperwork. The investment lineup may have been chosen by a salesperson years ago and never formally reviewed since.
3(21) adviser vs. 3(38) investment manager
Both are fiduciaries. The difference is who makes the decisions and who is responsible for them.
| 3(21) investment adviser | 3(38) investment manager | |
|---|---|---|
| Selects the funds | Recommends; the employer decides | Selects, with discretion |
| Monitors the funds | Monitors and reports recommendations | Monitors and acts on the results |
| Replaces underperforming funds | Recommends; the employer approves and implements | Replaces them under the investment policy |
| Discretion over investments | No | Yes |
| Responsibility for investment decisions | Shared with the employer | Rests with the manager for the decisions it makes |
| What the employer still does | Makes final investment decisions, selects and monitors the adviser, and all other fiduciary duties | Prudently selects and monitors the manager, plus all other fiduciary duties |
For a deeper look, read our article 3(38) Investment Manager vs. 3(21) Co-Fiduciary: What Is the Difference?
What we do as your 3(38) investment manager
- Write the investment policy. An investment policy statement sets out how funds are chosen, monitored and replaced, so decisions follow a written process.
- Build the menu. We select a focused lineup with attention to cost, share class, diversification and the plan's default investment (its QDIA).
- Monitor on a schedule. We review the lineup against the policy and report to you in plain English.
- Make changes when needed. When a fund no longer meets the policy, we replace it and coordinate the change with the recordkeeper and employee notices.
- Document the process. Each review is recorded, which supports your own fiduciary file.
Northshire Consulting serves as a 3(38) investment manager for retirement plans, as disclosed in our Form ADV. We are fee-only: we do not receive commissions, revenue sharing or other payments from the funds we choose.
What stays with you
Hiring a 3(38) manager does not take the employer out of the picture. The employer keeps responsibility for:
- Selecting and monitoring the manager. Choosing the manager prudently, reviewing its reports and replacing it if it is not doing the job.
- Reasonable fees. Making sure the plan's total costs are reasonable for the services received. See our 401(k) fee review.
- Timely deposits. Sending employee contributions to the plan promptly. Our article on late 401(k) deposits explains why that matters.
- Plan operations. Following the plan document, enrolling eligible employees, providing required notices and keeping the plan's fidelity bond in place.
Responsibility for the investment decisions the manager makes moves to the manager. Responsibility for overseeing the arrangement does not.
Is a 3(38) arrangement a fit?
It tends to work well when:
- Nobody at the company has the time or background to research and monitor funds.
- The plan has no investment committee, or the committee wants professional discretion.
- The current lineup has not been formally reviewed in years.
- The owner wants a written, repeatable process for investment decisions.
If you would rather keep the final say on every fund change, a 3(21) arrangement may suit you better. We are happy to talk through both.
Frequently asked questions
What is a 3(38) investment manager?
A 3(38) investment manager is a fiduciary named under section 3(38) of ERISA who has discretion to select, monitor and replace a plan's investments. Instead of recommending funds for the employer to approve, the manager makes those decisions and is responsible for them.
Does hiring a 3(38) manager remove all of my fiduciary liability?
No. Appointing a 3(38) manager shifts responsibility for the investment decisions it makes, but the employer keeps the duty to prudently select and monitor the manager. The employer also keeps other fiduciary responsibilities, such as making sure fees are reasonable and depositing employee contributions on time.
What is the difference between a 3(21) and a 3(38) advisor?
A 3(21) advisor recommends investments and shares fiduciary responsibility for that advice, but the employer makes and owns the final decisions. A 3(38) manager makes the investment decisions itself, with discretion, and takes responsibility for them.
Is a 3(38) manager right for a small business?
It often is. Small-business owners rarely have an investment committee or the time to research funds. A 3(38) arrangement puts the investment work with a professional while the owner focuses on overseeing the arrangement. Some owners prefer to keep final say, in which case a 3(21) relationship may fit better.
Does Northshire act as a 3(38) investment manager?
Yes. As described in our Form ADV, Northshire Consulting serves as a 3(38) investment manager for retirement plans. We are fee-only, so we do not receive commissions or revenue sharing from the funds we select.
Will I still have to do anything?
Yes, but less. You will review the manager's reports, keep records of that oversight, make sure fees stay reasonable, and handle the plan's administrative duties such as timely deposits and accurate eligibility. We help you document the investment side of that record.
Put the investment work in professional hands
Let us talk about your plan, your current lineup and how a 3(38) arrangement would divide responsibilities between us.
This page is for general education and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Appointing a 3(38) investment manager does not relieve a plan sponsor of its duty to prudently select and monitor the manager or of its other fiduciary responsibilities. Northshire Consulting, LLC is an investment adviser registered with the State of Connecticut; registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. See our Form ADV for details about our services and fees.
