For Connecticut business owners
Is Your Company's 401(k) Plan Costing Too Much?
Most business owners can tell you what their 401(k) match is. Far fewer can tell you what the plan costs, who is being paid, or whether the fees come out of the company's checkbook or the employees' accounts. A fee review answers those questions in plain English and shows how your plan compares with similar Connecticut plans.
Why 401(k) fees deserve a look
Fees are easy to overlook because most of them never show up as an invoice. They are deducted quietly from fund returns or participant accounts, a little at a time, year after year. Over a long career, the difference between a fairly priced plan and an expensive one can add up to a meaningful share of an employee's savings.
There is a legal side as well. ERISA requires the people who run a retirement plan to act prudently and solely in the interest of participants, and that includes making sure the plan pays only reasonable fees for the services it receives. The U.S. Department of Labor's guide, Understanding Retirement Plan Fees and Expenses, explains that duty and why it matters to small employers too.
Plans are rarely priced badly on purpose. More often the plan was set up years ago, the company has grown, and nobody has gone back to ask whether the original arrangement still fits.
The fees inside a 401(k)
Almost every plan's cost is made up of a handful of pieces. Knowing the names makes the paperwork much easier to read.
| Fee | What it pays for | How it usually shows up |
|---|---|---|
| Recordkeeping and administration | Tracking accounts, processing contributions and withdrawals, the participant website, statements, compliance testing and government filings | A percentage of plan assets, a flat or per-participant charge, a bill to the company, or a mix |
| Investment expenses | Running the mutual funds, collective trusts or other investments in the lineup | The expense ratio of each fund, taken out of the fund's returns |
| Revenue sharing | Part of a fund's expense ratio passed back to the recordkeeper or advisor to cover their fees | Built into the expense ratio, so it is easy to miss; disclosed in the 408(b)(2) notice |
| Advisor fees | Investment selection and monitoring, fiduciary support, employee education | A percentage of assets, a flat fee, or commissions paid through the products |
| Per-participant and transaction fees | Loans, distributions, QDROs, and other individual services | Charged to the account of the person using the service |
Revenue sharing deserves special attention. Two versions of the same fund can carry different expense ratios because one share class pays revenue sharing and another does not. Neither is wrong on its face, but you should know which one your plan uses and where the money goes.
Who pays: the plan or the company
Plan expenses can be paid from plan assets, which means participants bear them through their accounts, or by the company directly. Many small plans use a combination: the company pays a setup or base fee, and asset-based charges come out of the plan.
Paying some costs directly can be a meaningful benefit to employees, and fees the company pays are generally a business expense. Paying them from the plan is also permitted, as long as they are reasonable and proper plan expenses. A review lays out exactly how your plan splits the bill so you can decide whether the arrangement still makes sense.
Documents to gather
You probably have most of these already in email or in your provider's sponsor website.
- 408(b)(2) fee disclosures from the recordkeeper, advisor and any other covered service provider. See our guide to reading 408(b)(2) disclosures.
- Service agreements with each provider, including any amendments.
- The most recent Form 5500 with its schedules. Our Form 5500 basics article explains what is in it.
- The participant fee disclosure (often called the 404a-5 notice) that employees receive each year.
- The investment lineup with each fund's expense ratio and share class.
- The plan document or adoption agreement, which shows how the plan is designed.
That is all plan-level information. Please do not send employee names, balances, Social Security numbers or payroll files. A fee review does not need them.
How benchmark data helps, and where it stops
Every retirement plan with a filing requirement reports to the Department of Labor on Form 5500, and those filings are public. We have organized the filings for Connecticut plans under $25 million in assets, using filings received through December 2025, so we can compare a plan with others of similar size in the state: participation, contribution levels, and the costs that are reported.
That comparison is useful context. It is not a verdict, for a few reasons:
- Plans buy different services. A plan with hands-on employee education may reasonably cost more than one without.
- Fees are reported differently. Some costs paid by the company or embedded in fund expenses do not appear on the 5500 at all.
- Filings lag. The most recent public filing reflects a plan year that has already ended.
So we use the benchmarks alongside your actual fee disclosures, not in place of them. You can read more about our approach to 401(k) advice for Connecticut small businesses and in how to know whether your 401(k) fees are reasonable.
Our three-step review
- Gather. A short conversation about your plan and your goals for it, then you send the plan-level documents listed above. If anything is missing, we can usually help you request it from your provider.
- Review and benchmark. We add up what the plan pays and who receives it, check share classes and revenue sharing, and compare the results with similar Connecticut plans.
- Discuss the findings. We walk through a written summary in plain English: what you pay, what you get, how it compares, and the options worth considering, including when the best answer is to leave things as they are. You keep the summary as part of your plan's fiduciary file.
A fee review is quoted as a flat fee before work begins. We are a fee-only firm, so we do not receive commissions or revenue sharing from any provider or fund we evaluate. If you later want ongoing help, we can also serve as the plan's 3(38) investment manager, but a review comes with no obligation to change anything.
Frequently asked questions
How do I find out what my company's 401(k) actually costs?
Start with the 408(b)(2) fee disclosure your recordkeeper and advisor are required to give you as the plan sponsor. Together with the service agreements, the investment lineup with expense ratios and the most recent Form 5500, it shows who is paid, how much and by what method. Some costs are deducted from plan assets and some are billed to the company, so both need to be added up.
Are 401(k) fees required to be low?
No. Under ERISA, plan fiduciaries must make sure fees are reasonable for the services the plan receives. The cheapest plan is not automatically the best one. The question is whether the plan is paying a fair price for what it gets, and whether the company has a documented process for checking that.
What documents should I gather for a fee review?
The 408(b)(2) fee disclosures from each service provider, the service agreements, the most recent Form 5500 with its schedules, the participant fee disclosure (404a-5), the current investment lineup with expense ratios and share classes, and the plan document or adoption agreement. Plan-level documents are enough. Employee account details are not needed.
How is the Connecticut benchmark data used in a review?
We compare your plan's size, contribution rates and reported costs with similar Connecticut plans drawn from public Form 5500 filings for plans under $25 million in assets, using filings through December 2025. Benchmarks give context. They do not prove a plan is overpriced or well priced, because services, plan design and how fees are reported differ from plan to plan.
What does a 401(k) fee review cost?
A fee review is quoted as a flat fee before any work begins, so you know the cost up front. We are fee-only, which means we do not earn commissions or revenue sharing from any fund or provider we review.
Will a fee review lower my plan's fees?
It depends on what the review finds. Some plans are already priced fairly for what they receive; others have room to renegotiate, change share classes or rethink providers. Either way, the review gives you a written record that the company examined its fees, which is part of a fiduciary's job.
Find out what your plan really costs
Start with a short conversation about your plan. We will tell you which documents to gather and quote the review before any work begins.
This page is for general education and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Benchmark comparisons use public Form 5500 data and may not reflect every cost a plan pays or every service it receives. Northshire Consulting, LLC is an investment adviser registered with the State of Connecticut; registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. See our Form ADV for details about our services and fees.
